OMG! The Witcher Flop Era Is REAL! Season 4 Viewership Crashes 50 Percent As Liam Hemsworth Debut Fails To Land And HONEY The Fans Have The Receipts!
October 30, 2025
Spill the tea! The numbers are in and let’s just say someone at Netflix is definitely crying into their coffee this morning. The results from the premiere weekend of The Witcher Season 4 are officially on the board and it is a certified, grade A disaster.
We are SHOOK!
Sources deep within the streaming giant have confirmed the unthinkable: viewership for the highly anticipated, and highly controversial, new season has plummeted by a jaw-dropping 50 percent compared to the launch of Season 3. Ouch. That’s not just a dip, that’s a full-on cliff dive!
The Liam Hemsworth era of Geralt of Rivia has arrived, and it seems like half the audience decided to stay home. This brutal drop validates what fans have been screaming from the rooftops for over two years: No Henry Cavill, no Witcher.
The Ghost of Geralt Past
Let’s rewind the tape, shall we? The drama started back in 2022 when our beloved king of the nerds, Henry Cavill, announced he was hanging up his silver sword. The fandom was thrown into absolute chaos. While the official line was scheduling conflicts, the internet tea was piping hot with rumors that Cavill, a massive fan of the original Witcher books and games, was tired of the show's writers deviating from the source material.
He fought for Geralt, and when he couldn’t win, he walked. A total power move!
Netflix moved quickly, announcing that the younger Hemsworth brother, Liam Hemsworth, would be picking up the monster-slaying mantle. The reaction was… let's call it chilly. Despite Liam’s undeniable star power, the recasting felt like a betrayal to the millions who saw Cavill as the perfect, gruff, and surprisingly heartfelt embodiment of Geralt of Rivia.
Fans launched petitions. They threatened boycotts. They memed the decision into oblivion. And now? They’re pulling out the receipts and yelling “I TOLD YOU SO!” from every corner of the internet.
Hemsworth’s Impossible Task
To be fair, Liam Hemsworth was tossed a coin into an impossible situation. He had to fill the enormous, custom-made boots of an actor who not only looked the part but lived and breathed the lore.
When the first look images of Hemsworth in the Witcher gear dropped earlier this year, the internet had a field day. While some were willing to give him a chance, many felt he looked more like a Halloween costume than the grizzled White Wolf. The vibe was just… off.
Now, with the premiere numbers tanking, it's clear that the visual disconnect was just the tip of the iceberg. The audience's emotional connection to Cavill’s Geralt was the show's anchor, and without it, the ship is officially sinking in the turbulent waters of the streaming wars.
The Fandom Sounds Off And It Is LOUD
Twitter, or X, or whatever we’re calling it this week, is an absolute warzone.
One user tweeted, “Netflix thought they could just swap out Henry Cavill like a Ken doll and we wouldn’t notice? This 50% viewership drop is the best thing I’ve read all day. #TheWitcher #HenryCavillIsOurGeralt”
Another added, “Tried to watch the new Witcher. Lasted 10 minutes. It’s not just that Liam Hemsworth isn’t Henry Cavill. The whole show has lost its soul. It feels like a cheap knockoff. #JusticeForGeralt”
The sentiment is clear: this wasn't just about an actor. It was about respect for the source material and the passion that Henry Cavill brought to the role. Fans feel completely and totally validated in their two-year campaign against the change. This viewership crash isn’t just a statistic; it's a statement.
What Happens Now On The Continent?
This ratings catastrophe puts Netflix in a seriously awkward position. With a fifth and final season already planned, do they push forward with a show that’s hemorrhaging viewers? Or do they cut their losses?
And what about the rest of the incredible cast? Anya Chalotra as Yennefer, Freya Allan as Ciri, and Joey Batey as Jaskier are all caught in the crossfire of this recasting calamity. They continue to deliver amazing performances, but it seems even their combined star power can't save the show from the shadow of Cavill’s exit.
One thing is for certain: October 30, 2025, will go down in streaming history as the day the fans proved their point. They tossed their coin, and it was a resounding vote for the Geralt they fell in love with. The Hemsworth era has begun not with a bang, but with the deafening silence of millions of viewers changing the channel.
So what do YOU think? Did you tune in for Season 4, or did you join the boycott? Sound off in the comments below!
By: koalafriend
Leave a Reply